Platform Leakage: The Hidden Profit Killer & How to Fix It

What Is Marketplace Platform Leakage?

As marketplace experts who’ve built hundreds of successful platforms, we’ve seen one challenge consistently threaten even the most promising marketplaces: platform leakage.

Also known as disintermediation, platform leakage happens when users circumvent your payment system to transact directly, cutting out your commission. This silent revenue killer can undermine your entire business model if not properly addressed.

Marketplace leakage occurs when buyers and sellers who met on your platform take their transactions off-platform to avoid fees.

The scenario typically plays out in one of two ways:

• Users complete an initial transaction through your platform, but conduct subsequent transactions directly
• Users connect on your platform but arrange payment outside your system before completing their first transaction

The math makes it tempting: if your marketplace charges a 15% commission, both parties can split the difference and each save money by going direct. But while this seems like a win-win for them, it’s devastating for your platform.

---

Why Platform Leakage Happens

The fundamental equation is simple: leakage occurs when your commission exceeds the perceived value you provide in the transaction.

Users don’t bypass your platform because they’re trying to harm your business—they do it because they don’t see sufficient value in staying. The solution isn’t punishing users for leaving; it’s creating so much value they wouldn’t dream of it.

The Psychology Behind Platform Leakage

Leakage typically follows a predictable pattern. Initially, both providers and customers value your marketplace for making the connection possible—this is when your matching function provides clear value. However, once that connection is established and trust develops between parties, they begin to question the ongoing value of your commission.

This reassessment is triggered by specific moments:

• When a provider and customer establish direct communication
• After a successful first transaction creates trust
• When they realize how much commission they’re paying
• When they experience a pain point in your platform’s process

At these trigger points, users perform a rapid cost-benefit analysis: “Is the platform’s fee worth what I’m getting?” If your value isn’t immediately obvious, the economic incentive to go direct becomes compelling.

What makes this challenge particularly difficult is that your most successful matches—the providers and customers who have the best experiences—are often the most likely to leave. The better you are at creating strong matches, the more you need to deliver ongoing value beyond that initial connection.

Remember that platform leakage isn’t personal—it’s a natural economic behavior. Users aren’t being disloyal; they’re responding to incentives. Your job isn’t to restrict or punish this behavior, but to align your platform’s value with your commission structure so thoroughly that staying on-platform becomes the obviously superior choice.

---

The “Value Anchor” Strategy: Making Your Platform Indispensable

After helping launch and scale dozens of marketplaces, we’ve developed a framework called the “Value Anchor” strategy. This approach focuses on embedding your platform so deeply in the transaction process that going around it becomes more costly than your commission.

What Are Value Anchors?

Value anchors are specific platform features, tools, or protections that create substantial value for users and are inextricably tied to your payment system. They serve as “anchors” that keep transactions on your platform by making off-platform alternatives comparatively disadvantageous.

Effective value anchors share three key characteristics:

1. They solve genuine user problems that exist independent of your marketplace
2. They’re difficult or expensive to replicate outside your platform
3. They create ongoing value that extends beyond the initial match

Why Value Anchors Work

The fundamental psychology behind value anchors is simple but powerful: humans make decisions based on perceived value, not absolute cost. When users consider going off-platform, they mentally calculate:

Platform fee cost vs. Value lost by going direct

When your value anchors create benefits that clearly exceed your commission, staying on-platform becomes the rational economic choice.

The Four Types of Value Anchors

Different marketplace types require different anchoring strategies:

1. Trust Anchors

Best for: Transactions between strangers, high-risk exchanges, valuable goods/services

Trust anchors create security and confidence that would be absent in direct transactions. They’re especially powerful when:

• Transactions involve significant financial risk
• Physical safety or personal property is involved
• Parties have no pre-existing relationship

Examples include insurance coverage, identity verification, fraud protection, and dispute resolution.

2. Efficiency Anchors

Best for: Recurring transactions, professional service providers, operations-heavy businesses

Efficiency anchors save users time, reduce administrative burdens, and streamline operations. They’re most effective when:

• Providers manage multiple clients or bookings
• Services require significant pre/post transaction coordination
• Administrative tasks consume substantial provider time

Examples include scheduling systems, client management tools, automated invoicing, and service delivery workflows.

3. Growth Anchors

Best for: Competitive service categories, providers building businesses, premium marketplaces

Growth anchors help providers expand their customer base and increase earnings. They work best when:

• Providers compete for customer attention
• Building a reputation is valuable in the industry
• Providers are looking to scale their operations

Examples include algorithmic promotion, featured placement, performance badges, and marketing tools.

4. Experience Anchors

Best for: Consumer-facing marketplaces, frequency-driven platforms, convenience services

Experience anchors make the user journey noticeably better than direct alternatives. They’re most powerful when:

• Convenience is a key decision factor
• Multiple steps are required to complete transactions
• The direct alternative involves friction or awkwardness

Examples include one-click booking, stored payment methods, saved preferences, and seamless communication.

Implementation Framework

To effectively implement value anchors in your marketplace:

1. Identify friction points in the direct transaction process for your specific industry
2. Develop features that directly address these pain points
3. Integrate these features with your payment system so they’re only available for on-platform transactions
4. Continuously educate users about the value these anchors provide
5. Measure anchor effectiveness by tracking retention and repeat transaction rates

The right value anchors transform your commission from a “tax” on transactions into a fair payment for valuable services. When implemented effectively, users don’t just tolerate your commission—they recognize it as a worthwhile investment in a superior experience.

Let’s explore how to implement specific value anchors for different marketplace types:

---

For C2C Marketplaces: Trust & Security Features

In consumer-to-consumer marketplaces (where individuals offer products or services to other individuals), the primary value your platform provides is creating trust and security between strangers.

Why this works: Individual sellers and buyers lack established business infrastructure and face significant risks when transacting with strangers. By providing robust security features, your platform becomes the essential trust layer that makes transactions possible.

1. Comprehensive Insurance Coverage

Concept: Insurance protects both parties from the inherent risks of transacting with strangers, creating value that disappears when users go off-platform. The protection must be substantial enough that sacrificing it to save on commission feels like a poor trade-off.

Example: Turo’s car-sharing marketplace offers up to $750,000 in liability insurance that activates only when bookings are processed through their platform. This coverage makes off-platform transactions extremely risky for both parties, as a single accident could cost far more than the cumulative commissions saved.

2. Robust Verification Systems

Concept: By thoroughly vetting users on both sides of the marketplace, you create a trust layer that neither party could easily replicate on their own. This verification becomes increasingly valuable as transaction values increase.

Example: Airbnb’s verification system combines ID verification, social profile linking, and user reviews. This multi-layered approach creates significantly higher trust than two strangers could establish independently, making their commission worthwhile for the peace of mind it provides.

3. Dispute Resolution

Concept: A trusted third-party mediator becomes invaluable when transactions don’t go as planned. A fair, accessible dispute resolution system becomes insurance against potential conflicts.

Example: eBay’s Money Back Guarantee provides buyers with protection against items not received or not as described. This system, which includes a structured resolution process with clear timelines and escalation paths, has become a key reason why eBay maintains transaction loyalty despite numerous cheaper alternatives.

4. Reputation Systems That Create Real Value

Concept: Well-designed reputation systems create portable trust that becomes valuable to users beyond any single transaction. As users accumulate positive reviews, they develop an incentive to continue transacting on-platform to maintain and enhance this valuable asset.

Example: TaskRabbit’s reputation system combines ratings, reviews, and completion metrics to create an “Elite Tasker” status that directly impacts earning potential. Taskers who achieve this status receive priority placement in search results and can command higher rates, creating a powerful incentive to keep transactions on-platform even as their client relationships deepen.

---

For B2C Marketplaces: Professional Business Tools

In business-to-consumer marketplaces (where professional providers offer services to customers), the most effective leakage prevention comes from providing essential business management functionality.

Why this works: Professional service providers need operational tools to run their businesses efficiently. When these tools are integrated with your platform, providers become dependent on your ecosystem for their daily operations, making off-platform transactions inefficient.

1. End-to-End Business Management Systems

Concept: By providing comprehensive tools that handle mundane but essential business operations, your marketplace becomes a critical business infrastructure that professionals rely on daily, not just for finding clients.

Example: Upwork’s platform handles everything from proposals and contracts to time tracking, invoicing, and payment processing for freelancers. This integrated system automates tasks that would otherwise require multiple separate tools and manual processes, making their commission feel like a fair trade for the operational efficiency gained.

2. Advanced Booking & Availability Management

Concept: Sophisticated scheduling tools that optimize a provider’s availability and maximize their earning potential create value that extends far beyond simple matchmaking.

Example: StyleSeat’s booking system for beauty professionals includes smart scheduling features that automatically suggest optimal appointment lengths, minimize gaps between bookings, and help professionals maximize their daily revenue. These tools have been shown to increase provider earnings by 15-30%, far exceeding the platform’s commission.

3. Growth & Marketing Tools

Concept: Tools that help providers market themselves and grow their client base become a compelling reason to keep transactions on-platform, especially when these tools leverage platform-specific data and reach.

Example: Fiverr’s algorithm promotes sellers based on their on-platform performance metrics, giving high-performing sellers significant visibility advantages. This algorithmic promotion becomes a powerful customer acquisition channel that sellers can’t replicate off-platform, making the commission worthwhile for the marketing value alone.

4. Financial Services & Benefits

Concept: Access to financial tools and benefits that are only available through the platform creates significant value beyond the transaction itself, especially when these services address pain points specific to the provider’s industry.

Example: Uber Pro offers drivers access to free education through Arizona State University online, discounted car maintenance, gas savings, and other benefits tied to their continued platform usage. These benefits, which would be difficult or impossible for drivers to access independently, create value that often exceeds the platform’s commission.

---

For Customers: Friction Reduction Anchors

Creating an experience so smooth that customers prefer on-platform transactions is crucial to preventing leakage from the demand side.

1. Seamless Payment Experiences

Concept: By removing friction from the payment process, you make the on-platform experience noticeably better than the often awkward direct payment alternatives, especially for recurring transactions.

Example: At Directorism, all our marketplaces are built with the most frictionless booking and payment funnels possible. We implement intuitive checkout flows that minimize steps and incorporate popular seamless payment methods like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and other one-click purchasing famous methods. This approach eliminates the need for customers to manually enter payment details for each transaction or handle awkward direct payment situations, making the platform experience significantly smoother than going direct. When customers can complete a booking in seconds rather than minutes, the convenience alone justifies your commission.

2. Buyer Protection Programs

Concept: Protection against potential problems with a purchase creates significant peace of mind that disappears in direct transactions, making your commission feel like a worthwhile insurance premium.

Example: StockX authenticates every luxury item and sneaker sold through their platform, eliminating the risk of counterfeit products. This authentication process, which would be unavailable in direct transactions, gives buyers confidence that justifies the platform’s fees, particularly for high-value items.

3. Smart Retention Incentives

Concept: Loyalty programs that reward continued platform usage create economic incentives for customers to keep transactions on-platform, even when direct alternatives exist.

Example: Grubhub’s rewards program gives customers points for each dollar spent, eventually unlocking free delivery and other perks. These benefits, which accumulate with platform usage, create a compelling reason for customers to continue ordering through the app rather than contacting restaurants directly.

4. Post-Purchase Support

Concept: Support services that extend beyond the initial transaction create ongoing value that disappears when users go direct, particularly for complex products or services.

Example: Reverb (instrument marketplace) provides dedicated support for issues that might arise after purchase, including authenticity questions and shipping problems. This post-purchase safety net becomes particularly valuable for high-ticket items like vintage guitars, where problems might emerge weeks after the transaction is complete.

---

Communication Strategies: The Right & Wrong Approaches

While your primary focus should be providing value, strategic communication can reinforce platform usage. However, this approach requires careful implementation.

Effective Approaches:

1. Value Education: Most users aren’t fully aware of all the protections and benefits they receive through on-platform transactions. Regular, non-intrusive reminders about these benefits can significantly reduce leakage. Example: Airbnb periodically sends hosts informational content about their $1M Host Protection Insurance and explains how it only applies to bookings made through the platform.
2. Community Building: Creating a sense that on-platform transactions support a broader community can tap into users’ desire to contribute to something larger than themselves. Example: Etsy regularly communicates how seller fees support their Seller Education Fund and sustainability initiatives, framing commissions as contributions to the artisan community rather than just platform fees.
3. Transparent Fee Explanation: Users are more accepting of fees when they understand exactly what they fund and how they enable better experiences. Example: Deliveroo breaks down their fees to show how they support rider earnings, restaurant partnerships, and platform maintenance, making the value exchange more explicit and acceptable to users.

Ineffective Approaches to Avoid:

1. Threatening Messages: Warnings about account termination for off-platform transactions typically create resentment rather than compliance.
2. Excessive Communication Restrictions: While some contact limitations make sense, overly aggressive filtering of contact information creates user frustration and works against building trust.
3. Punitive Policies: Punishing users suspected of platform leakage often catches innocent users in the crossfire and damages your community.

The Directorism Approach: Building Marketplaces Users Never Want to Leave

At Directorism, we don’t just fight platform leakage—we make it completely irrational by creating ecosystems so valuable that users actively prefer staying on-platform:

1. Professional Tools That Create Dependency

We build comprehensive SaaS tools directly into marketplaces that become essential to providers’ daily operations. These include client management dashboards, automated scheduling, custom-branded booking widgets, financial reporting, and inventory management. When these tools are seamlessly integrated with your payment system, providers realize that saving 15% commission would actually cost them 30% more in external software and lost efficiency. You may read more about marketplace SaaS tools that also help solving the chicken-and-egg problem.

2. Incentives That Make Suppliers Your Anti-Leakage Advocates

We implement sophisticated ranking algorithms and gamification systems that reward on-platform loyalty. Professional photographers on one marketplace receive preferential search placement based on their “Platform Score”—combining booking volume, review quality, and response rates. This algorithmic advantage becomes so valuable that suppliers themselves will refuse customers’ attempts to go off-platform, as it would damage their visibility and future earnings. We have tons of ways to make your Suppliers actually fight for in-house bookings and payments and crave to pay your comission. Learn how to transform your Suppliers your free organic marketing channel.

3. Frictionless End-to-End User Experience

We design every touchpoint to be remarkably easier than direct alternatives. From discovering providers through intelligent matching algorithms, to seamless booking flows requiring just 2-3 taps, to stored payment methods and automatic receipt generation—the entire journey eliminates friction points that exist in direct transactions. When booking takes seconds instead of minutes, your commission becomes a convenience fee users gladly pay.

4. Loyalty Programs That Create Economic Incentives

We build multi-sided rewards systems that make platform usage financially advantageous beyond a single transaction. Customers earn points for bookings that translate to discounts or premium features. Suppliers unlock tiered benefits like reduced commissions or featured placement after reaching transaction milestones. These progressive rewards create powerful economic reasons to keep all activity on-platform. You may read more about economic incentives that also help solving the chicken-and-egg problem.

5. Basic Leakage Prevention That Doesn’t Create Friction

While our primary approach is value-creation, we also implement essential protective measures:

• Smart contact detection that identifies phone numbers and emails in messages without blocking legitimate communication
• Revealing full contact details only after confirmed bookings
• Two-way anonymous messaging until transaction completion
• Watermarking portfolio images to prevent off-platform solicitation

6. Strategic Value Education

We design user interfaces that subtly highlight the platform’s value throughout the journey. A “Protection Active” indicator appears during transactions, itemizing the specific guarantees and services (payment protection, verification, insurance) being provided at that moment—making the invisible benefits visible exactly when users are most likely to consider going direct.

The key insight behind our approach: The platform should create so much value that users actively fight to stay on it. We’ve seen suppliers actually reporting customers who suggest going direct because they recognize the platform’s long-term value exceeds any short-term commission savings.

When you build a truly valuable marketplace ecosystem, you’ll find your biggest leakage prevention allies are your users themselves. They’ll recognize that the platform isn’t just taking a cut—it’s creating an experience and infrastructure that benefits everyone far beyond what they could create on their own.

The Golden Rule: Create More Value Than You Capture

The fundamental principle in preventing marketplace leakage is ensuring you create substantially more value than you capture through commissions. Your platform should make transactions so much better that your fee feels like a bargain, not a tax.

Remember that your providers and customers aren’t your adversaries—they’re your partners. When you genuinely improve their experience and help them achieve better outcomes, platform leakage naturally diminishes.

By implementing the strategies outlined in this guide and continuously innovating on the value you provide, you can transform platform leakage from an existential threat into a minor concern while building a more defensible, valuable marketplace.